I have to give it to Madonna for an artist who has been around nearly 3 decades she can still get the crowd going. As for her singing over these hard beats to say the least terrible Lastly 300,000 first week that's good considering today's music climate but I expected more considering Madge's fan base. Could it be the younger generation is not buying into the hip hop Madonna?

My ears are still bleeding after 5 secs of "Hung Up"or as i'd call it "Pitch Up". Horrendous

I LOVE this album - in my opinion, it's the best purchase I've made this year (closely followed by Estelle). Sure, the performance was "pitchy" - and I hate that word - but who goes to a concert to hear perfection? If the tickets cost anywhere near the ones for the Drowned World tour, I'll need to start the paperwork for a home equity loan because I'll definitely be there!

Madonna is def not the best singer... but she does work a crowd well and most of her songs r pretty good! Though Justin made her sound not sooo good, cuz he sounds great live in my opinion!

IT WAS A HOT SHOW, IT HAD A FEW TECHNICAL PROBLEMS BUT, MADONNA ROCKED. GO COP THE #1 ALBUM HARD CANDY IT'S HOT!

Madonna's Hard Candy is a great album.

Hard Candy is terrible and she looks so out of her element doing "Candy Shop" and "Four Minutes."

Madonna & Rihanna don't have the best voice, but they always pick the right songs and know how to work with what they got

Yep She Was Right About Here Sugar is RAW Yes thats because it out of date maddona needs to sit here old cant sing cant dance ass down and people compare here to janet

"My ears are still bleeding after 5 secs of "Hung Up"or as i'd call it "Pitch Up". Horrendous"

yes, madonna can't sing. she sounds horrible.

according to perez hilton's site madonna's album is dropping like a stone. time to retire granny.